| Platinum | Faithe's Sweet Treats |
| Platinum | Laurie's Cookies |
| Gold | At Your Bake & Call |
| Gold | Lynn's Bakery Deli & Catering |
| Silver | The Cookie Place |
| Bronze | The Pie Boss |
| Top Pick | Generations Bakery |
| Top Pick | Inside The Cookie Jar |
| Top Pick | Patrelle's Bakery & Sweet Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Purple Lips Bakery |