| Platinum | Tuscanos Pizzeria & Bistro |
| Gold | Dolcetto |
| Silver | Pizzeria Madre |
| Silver | Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar |
| Bronze | Angelo’s Italian Bakery & Market |
| Top Pick | Fat Olive |
| Top Pick | Fellini Koolini's |
| Top Pick | Porcino |
| Top Pick | Spageddy Eddy's |
| Top Pick | Tony's Famous Italian Restaurant |